News

Debating Open Access

July 1, 2013 1782

The furious controversies of last year following the announcement of the new Research Councils UK policies on open access may have quietened down, but there remain many practical problems. These practical problems could well be amplified by proposals from HEFCE to require open access publication of anything due to be submitted to the next Research Excellence Framework in 2020.

The essential point, it seems to us, is this. The position that open access is ethically necessary and/or inevitable, and the position that it has so many practical problems attached to it that it risks being pointlessly destructive unless they are resolved, both seem the obvious starting-point to substantial groups of researchers. So obvious, indeed, that it is often not necessary to take seriously the other position at all. But if academics and other research practitioners do not create a solution for themselves, others with less knowledge and insight will continue to do it for them, and very likely get it wrong.

Debating Open Access is a collection of a series of 8 newly commissioned articles reflecting on the challenges and opportunities for humanities and social sciences open-access publishing practices. Edited by British Academy Vice-Presidents Professor Nigel Vincent and Professor Chris Wickham the collection demonstrates that there is still much work to be done in ensuring that government policies to mandate open access publication do not damage the quality and reputation of UK academic research

The collection includes contributions from experts across the spectrum of humanities and social sciences research:

  • Dr Rita Gardner, Director of the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG) on the risks and opportunities of open access for learned societies
  • Professor Stuart M. Shieber, founding director of Harvard University’s Office for Scholarly Communication on how the principles of the Finch Report have been lost in the government’s implementation of the recommendations
  • Professor Chris Wickham, British Academy Vice President (Publications) on how open access might restrict the freedom of academics to publish their work in international journals
  • Professor Stephen Curry of Imperial College on the need for scholars to play their part in making sure open access works effectively
  • Dr Martin Paul Eve, director of the Open Library of the Humanities on the possibilities of using open access publication to make peer review a more collaborative, less elitist process
  • Ziyad Marar, Global Publishing Director at SAGE on the role of publishers in supporting the creation of authoritative, credible scholarly knowledge
  • Professor Robin Osborne of Cambridge University on how open access could lead to lower quality research publications
  • Professor Nigel Vincent, British Academy Vice President (Research and Higher Education) on why open access cannot be allowed to risk the continuing importance of the monograph in HSS research.

Download the full collection or read individual essays.

The British Academy is the UK’s national body which champions and supports the humanities and social sciences. It is an independent, self-governing fellowship of scholars, elected for their distinction in research and publication. Our purpose is to inspire, recognise and support excellence in the humanities and social sciences, throughout the UK and internationally, and to champion their role and value.

View all posts by British Academy

Related Articles

Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics
News
March 27, 2024

Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics

Read Now
2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe
News
March 14, 2024

2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

Read Now
New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible
Impact
March 4, 2024

New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible

Read Now
Contemporary Politics Focus of March Webinar Series
News
February 21, 2024

Contemporary Politics Focus of March Webinar Series

Read Now
There’s Something In the Air…But Is It a Virus? Part 1

There’s Something In the Air…But Is It a Virus? Part 1

The historic Hippocrates has become an iconic figure in the creation myths of medicine. What can the body of thought attributed to him tell us about modern responses to COVID?

Read Now
The Social Sciences Are Under Attack in Higher Education

The Social Sciences Are Under Attack in Higher Education

The social sciences have been a consistent target for political operatives around the United States in recent years., and recent actions at the state level have opened a new front in the long-running conflict.

Read Now
Jonathan Breckon On Knowledge Brokerage and Influencing Policy

Jonathan Breckon On Knowledge Brokerage and Influencing Policy

Overton spoke with Jonathan Breckon to learn about knowledge brokerage, influencing policy and the potential for technology and data to streamline the research-policy interface.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments