Higher Education Reform

Between the Public Good and Private Pursuits Higher Education Reform
An inscription on the Jefferson building at the U.S. Library of Congress.

Between the Public Good and Private Pursuits

November 23, 2015 1388

An inscription on the Jefferson building at the U.S. Library of Congress.

An inscription on the Jefferson building at the U.S. Library of Congress.

This month the board of Elsevier’s owned Lingua resigned in protest over prices the company charges to university libraries. This resignation is indicative of a larger malaise surrounding public access to knowledge and the fruits of research.

The private education industry is estimated at $4.4 trillion worldwide. Academic publishers rely largely on the free labor offered by researchers and writers. This includes the academic reviewing of publishable research and the editing of journals. Academics receive nominal (if any) compensation. Meanwhile, many universities cannot afford to subscribe to the journals that their faculty generously donate their time and knowledge to.

Michelle L. Stack

Michelle L. Stack

Why would universities agree to participate in a business structure antithetical to commitments to making knowledge freely and publicly accessible?

To understand this paradox we need to more closely examine the intersecting interests within the privatized education sector. In particular we need more research that analyzes the relationship between university rankings, citation indexes, and academic publishers.

Major rankers, such as The Times Higher Education World University Ranking and QS, use Elsevier’s or Thomson Reuter’s citation indexes to determine the research productivity of universities. In turn, Elsevier is also the world’s biggest journal publisher – and publication in journals helps determine a university’s productivity. Rankings matter for government allocation of funds, student numbers and industry investments. Not surprisingly, cash-strapped universities frequently pressure their faculty to publish in journals most likely to assist with a high ranking.

It gets stranger, however. Universities provide free information for media generated rankings: Information collected by staff hired, often, with public dollars. Universities also buy what is sold back to them by these companies in the form of products and services aimed at assisting universities in improving their ranking. Benchmarking products are created based on data provided — for free — by universities.

Universities are platinum donors to private education industry who use the largesse to further erode the public role of universities. While Elsevier, Thomson Reuters, and connected ranking products increase profits, students are graduating with a lifetime of debt and many others can’t afford to attend university. If a university is merely a product like any other, why would the public be dedicated to contributing public budgets to support it? Universities might get short term gains in the form of a higher ranking or a building thrown in here or there. However, in the longer term the public loses the one place that is supported to challenge to promote a more equitable social, economic, and political order.

Hence, the struggle is not just a fight about the cost of knowledge. It is also about universities operating as part and parcel of the public good . There are alternatives that could be considered, however. Universities, for example, might look to the Netherlands who called for a boycott of Elsevier journals to protest the outrageous fees charged to libraries.

If we want universities to be something more than another business, we need to join efforts to build an alternative network that promotes and expands access and the sharing of knowledge and research outcomes in equitable and socially transformative ways.


Michelle Stack is associate professor in the Department of Educational Studies at the University of British Columbia, Canada. Her research centers on the role of media and market logics in the transformation of education; media education; and media-academic communication aimed at expanding public debate about what a good education is. Prior to becoming an academic Michelle was a communications director and policy consultant. Michelle can also be found on twitter at @MichelleLStack

View all posts by Michelle L. Stack

Related Articles

AI Upskilling Can and Should Empower Business School Faculty
Higher Education Reform
July 10, 2024

AI Upskilling Can and Should Empower Business School Faculty

Read Now
Reflections of a Former Student Body President: ‘Student Government is a Thankless Job’
Insights
July 1, 2024

Reflections of a Former Student Body President: ‘Student Government is a Thankless Job’

Read Now
Universities Should Reimagine Governance Along Co-Operative Lines
Higher Education Reform
May 20, 2024

Universities Should Reimagine Governance Along Co-Operative Lines

Read Now
Striving for Linguistic Diversity in Scientific Research
Communication
May 1, 2024

Striving for Linguistic Diversity in Scientific Research

Read Now
The Power of Fuzzy Expectations: Enhancing Equity in Australian Higher Education

The Power of Fuzzy Expectations: Enhancing Equity in Australian Higher Education

Having experienced firsthand the transformational power of education, the authors wanted to shed light on the contemporary challenges faced by regional and remote university students.

Read Now
Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact

Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact

Drawing on the findings of a workshop on making translational research design principles the norm for European research, Gabi Lombardo, Jonathan Deer, Anne-Charlotte Fauvel, Vicky Gardner and Lan Murdock discuss the characteristics of translational research, ways of supporting cross disciplinary collaboration, and the challenges and opportunities of adopting translational principles in the social sciences and humanities.

Read Now
Addressing the United Kingdom’s Lack of Black Scholars

Addressing the United Kingdom’s Lack of Black Scholars

In the UK, out of 164 university vice-chancellors, only two are Black. Professor David Mba was recently appointed as the first Black vice-chancellor […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments