Business and Management INK

Wage Inequality Offers Short-Term Boost and Long-Term Problem

August 23, 2021 2763

The pandemic put a spotlight on the growth of wage inequality between top managers and employees. As The New York Times wrote: “While millions of people struggled to make ends meet, many of the companies hit hardest in 2020 showered their executives with riches.”

Results show that unequal wages between top managers and employees can boost the short-term profitability of a firm. In the long run, however, this benefit fades. What persists is that wage inequality motivates employees to opportunistically exploit customers and weakens a firm’s customer-oriented culture, thereby harming customer satisfaction.

How does this happen? In firms with high wage inequality, there is a strong incentive for employees to work hard to reach higher paying positions in management. But in the process, our findings show that they are more likely to engage in opportunistic behaviors and also collaborate less with coworkers. For example, to enhance her chances for promotion, an employee might show more effort by interacting with customers more frequently to better understand and fulfill their needs to boost sales. By contrast, she could also distort facts about products to close deals more quickly.

Non-customer-facing employees could also be affected. Take, for instance, an R&D employee. He could interact with customers more often to learn and adapt innovations to their needs to increase sales. Conversely, he could also design products to fail to force customers to buy a product over and over again.

This blog post by Boas Bamberger was originally published in a similar version in the Journal of Marketing blog. It is based on the article “Wage Inequality: Its Impact on Customer Satisfaction and Firm Performance,” by Boas Bamberger, Christian Homburg and Dominik M. Wielgos appearing in the Journal of Marketing.

At the same time, wage inequality might also weaken collaboration among coworkers. An employee who worries about advancing to the next higher level is less concerned about her coworkers. But less collaboration impairs the flows of information and knowledge about customers throughout the firm. This, in turn, can lead to worse coordination between departments. Ultimately, the firm becomes less responsive to the changing needs of customers. We find that wage inequality weakens the customer-oriented culture of a firm.

Our findings show that wage inequality does raise the firm’s short-run profits directly. However, the adverse impact wage inequality has on opportunism and customer-oriented culture ultimately extends to customer satisfaction and reduces these short-term profits although the effect remains weakly positive.

We find this weak positive effect on short-term profitability holds in a different sample with more than 500 observations of U.S. firms selling to consumers. But when we analyzed how wage inequality plays out in the long run, the situation reverses. The harm that wage inequality costs to customer satisfaction siphons away positive benefit of wage inequality. In sum, a firm sees no profitability lift from wage inequality in the long run.

Do firms have an incentive to raise wage inequality? In terms of bottom-line impact, the answer is: “Yes” in the short run and “No” in the long run. However, when looking at the customer impact, the answer is “No” because of the negative impact of wage inequality on customer satisfaction, which weakens firm profits.

What can managers learn? If you aim for short-term profitability, go with higher wage inequality but keep an eye on the types of negative employee behaviors that can hurt customers and your firm’s customer-oriented culture—and ultimately weaken customer satisfaction. If you are interested in the long-term success of your firm, consider reducing wage inequality to help your team orient toward customers instead of competing for more wages.

What can shareholders learn? Suppose that you care about the long-term profitability of your investment. In that case, make sure to reward top managers for achieving sustainable profitability and good customer relationships.

What can policymakers learn? Wage inequality is not in a firm’s long-term interest. This argument can help to create a consensus with managers to restrain wage inequality. However, short-term-oriented managers might care little about the damage wage inequality does to society. It thus might be necessary to disincentivize them from raising wage inequality.

Boas Bamberger is a researcher on strategic market management at the University of Mannheim. His research investigates how top teams decide on how companies relate and trade to create, evolve and govern markets.

View all posts by Boas Bamberger

Related Articles

Boards and Internationalization Speed
Business and Management INK
November 18, 2024

Boards and Internationalization Speed

Read Now
How Managers Can Enhance Trust
Business and Management INK
November 11, 2024

How Managers Can Enhance Trust

Read Now
The Role of Place in Sustainability
Business and Management INK
October 28, 2024

The Role of Place in Sustainability

Read Now
Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices
Business and Management INK
October 24, 2024

Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices

Read Now
Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

In this article, co-authors Natalie Slawinski, Bruna Brito, Jennifer Brenton, and Wendy Smith reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Reflections on deep academic–practitioner partnering for generative societal impact,” published in Strategic Organization.

Read Now
Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Charlie Smith reflects on his interest in psychedelic research, the topic of his research article, “Psychedelics, Psychedelic-Assisted Therapy and Employees’ Wellbeing,” published in Journal of Management Inquiry.

Read Now
Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Co-authors Birgitte Wraae and Nicolai Nybye reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Learning to Be “Me,” “the Team,” and “the Company” Through Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities: An Ethnographic Approach,” published in Entrepreneurship Education and Pedagogy.

Read Now
5 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments