Business and Management INK

From Speculation to Substantiation: Is Job Satisfaction Changing?

February 16, 2022 1866
Medieval illustration of men harvesting wheat with reaping-hooks
The authors’ findings suggest that workers in recent years are more dissatisfied by jobs that do not meet their desires for intrinsically motivating work. (Image: Calendar page for August in Queen Mary’s Psalter)

In this article, authors Mindy Shoss, an associate professor of psychology in the industrial/organizational psychology program at the University of Central Florida, and Clair Kueny, an assistant professor of psychological science at Missouri University of Science and Technology, reflect on their research surrounding the testing of societal changes over nearly 30 years that was published in Group & Organization Management.

There is much speculation about how workers’ expectations and attitudes towards their jobs have changed over the past several decades. The business, popular, and academic presses are replete with articles proclaiming that workers are more focused than ever on making sure their jobs meet their checklists of ideal job characteristics. Employees are told to “find their passion” and to “take charge of their careers.” Employers are advised to stay on top of these changing trends or risk losing people and productivity due to job dissatisfaction.

Although these presumed changes are frequently discussed, very little data has been used to shed light on whether these changes have actually occurred. We realized that a large national survey, the Work Orientations Modules of the International Social Survey Programme, would have data to test this question. In 1989, 1998, 2006, and 2016, samples of workers were asked questions about (1) their ideal job characteristics, (2) the job characteristics on their current job, and (3) their job satisfaction. Specifically, workers were asked to consider how important it is to them that a job is (1) meaningful, (2) helps other people, and (3) is useful to society. Then, they were asked to indicate the extent to which their current job had those characteristics. These three characteristics capture work that is said to be intrinsically-motivating—motivation which comes from the work itself.

Mindy Shoss, left, and Clair Kueny

Through advanced statistical methods, we found that there is indeed some evidence to suggest that workers’ reactions to fit between ideal and actual job characteristics has changed over time. Our findings suggest that workers in recent years are more dissatisfied by jobs that do not meet their desires for intrinsically motivating work. That is, for those who desire work that is meaningful, helps others, and is useful for society, not getting this type of work has become a greater source of dissatisfaction in recent decades.

What does this mean for employers and for the broader narrative that how workers approach work has changed? In more recent times, workers do appear to be more dissatisfied by work that does not meet their expectations. We see this as something positive. Workers who want to make a difference are less satisfied in positions where they can’t accomplish these goals. Given major societal needs/challenges at present, those anticipated to occur in the future, and the psychological benefits of intrinsically-motivating work, we see anything that may move organizations to offer more work that is meaningful and beneficial for society as a good thing.

As for our understanding of the psychology of the workforce, our research suggests that theories and methods should consider that people may evaluate job characteristics in light of broader social/economic/historical trends. We hope our work encourages other research along these lines.

Mindy Shoss, (pictured) is an associate professor of psychology in the industrial/organizational psychology program at the University of Central Florida. Clair Kueny is an associate professor of psychological sciences at Missouri S&T.

View all posts by Mindy Shoss and Clair Kueny

Related Articles

Boards and Internationalization Speed
Business and Management INK
November 18, 2024

Boards and Internationalization Speed

Read Now
How Managers Can Enhance Trust
Business and Management INK
November 11, 2024

How Managers Can Enhance Trust

Read Now
The Role of Place in Sustainability
Business and Management INK
October 28, 2024

The Role of Place in Sustainability

Read Now
Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices
Business and Management INK
October 24, 2024

Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices

Read Now
Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

In this article, co-authors Natalie Slawinski, Bruna Brito, Jennifer Brenton, and Wendy Smith reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Reflections on deep academic–practitioner partnering for generative societal impact,” published in Strategic Organization.

Read Now
Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Charlie Smith reflects on his interest in psychedelic research, the topic of his research article, “Psychedelics, Psychedelic-Assisted Therapy and Employees’ Wellbeing,” published in Journal of Management Inquiry.

Read Now
Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Co-authors Birgitte Wraae and Nicolai Nybye reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Learning to Be “Me,” “the Team,” and “the Company” Through Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities: An Ethnographic Approach,” published in Entrepreneurship Education and Pedagogy.

Read Now
4 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments