Business and Management INK

Reflecting on the ‘Curated Debate’ Over Using ‘Templates’ in Qualitative Research

August 22, 2022 1587
Black and white staged picture of two boxers in fighting stance with fists extended and referee in background.
While the lively debate over using templates for qualitative inquiry might be more scholarly than pugilistic, as demonstrated in Denny Gioia’s collection of responses noted below, it’s just as real as the 1914 ‘curated debate’ between Marty Cutler and Jack Johnson. (Photo: Library of Congress)

Denny Gioia of Pennsylvania State University’s Smeal College of Business reflects on the paper. “Curated Debate: On Using ‘Templates’ in Qualitative Research,” that he and 14 co-authors saw published in the Journal of Management Inquiry.

Do you like a good academic fight? A little gloves-off fisticuffs about what might be viewed from afar as some sort of arcane academic debate, but really isn’t? Rather, the central concern here is actually a debate-in-disguise about an issue with wide-ranging philosophical and practical implications. One of the currently raging issues in our field has to do with the use of “templates” in qualitative research – and qualitative research is back on the rise in academia because it is once again recognized as having the ability to convey a richer understanding of many organizational dynamics, especially those related to key processes. One of the prime targets for accusations that “rigorous” approaches to doing and presenting qualitative research (i.e., those that use what might be construed as templates) is a methodology that I have been developing and honing for over 30 years. That methodology has now become a prime target for assertions that its use is somehow ruining qualitative research. Those assertions have stirred an interesting little debate.

The big issues associated with the debate run the risk of dropping out of sight if this issue is viewed as one of interest only to qualitative cognoscenti. It’s not. To explore many of the issues surrounding the debate, I invited a number of the contributors to a special issue that recently appeared in Organizational Research Methods to either reiterate or elaborate their stances or to write a rejoinder to an essay I wrote to kick off the debate (i.e., Jacqueline Mees-Buss, Rebecca Piekkari & Catherine Welch, Jane Le & Torsten Schmid, and Karen Locke, Martha Feldman & Karen Golden-Biddle). I also invited a couple of well-known scholars (Ann Langley and Kathy Eisenhardt) to write statements about their approaches to doing qualitative research. Furthermore, I invited a number of scholars with a long history of using the targeted methodology to articulate the benefits of using a systematic approach to qualitative research (Davide Ravasi, Claus Rerup and Kevin Corley).

Finally, I also invited David Silverman to offer a rejoinder to my blistering attack on him, not only because I had singled him out, but also because he is a well-recognized qualitative scholar in his own right. All these folks are good sports, particularly those whom I assailed in the essay that serves as a trigger for the debate. 

If you enjoy reading short pieces from a group of people who know how to think in an insightful way and know how to write in a readable fashion, you should have a look at this curated debate about a topic that should interest all of us, not just those who do qualitative research.

Dennis A. Gioia is the Robert and Judith Auritt Klein Professor of Management in the Department of Management and Organization. Gioia is a member of the MBA core faculty, as well as the Executive MBA core faculty. He also is a former faculty director of the Developing Managerial Effectiveness executive program, and has served as a faculty leader in many other executive development programs for both private and public organizations. His current research deals with sensemaking and sensegiving processes during strategic change efforts, knowledge transformation processes, the role of organizational identity and image in attempting to accomplish change, and identity formation and change processes.

View all posts by Dennis Gioia

Related Articles

The Role of Place in Sustainability
Business and Management INK
October 28, 2024

The Role of Place in Sustainability

Read Now
Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices
Business and Management INK
October 24, 2024

Turning to Glitter in Management Studies – Why We Should Take ‘Unserious’ Glitter Serious to Understand New Management Practices

Read Now
Exploring the ‘Publish or Perish’ Mentality and its Impact on Research Paper Retractions
Research
October 10, 2024

Exploring the ‘Publish or Perish’ Mentality and its Impact on Research Paper Retractions

Read Now
Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact
Business and Management INK
September 17, 2024

Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

Read Now
Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Charlie Smith reflects on his interest in psychedelic research, the topic of his research article, “Psychedelics, Psychedelic-Assisted Therapy and Employees’ Wellbeing,” published in Journal of Management Inquiry.

Read Now
Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Co-authors Birgitte Wraae and Nicolai Nybye reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Learning to Be “Me,” “the Team,” and “the Company” Through Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities: An Ethnographic Approach,” published in Entrepreneurship Education and Pedagogy.

Read Now
The Future of Business is Interdisciplinary 

The Future of Business is Interdisciplinary 

By actively collaborating with industry, developing interdisciplinary programs and investing in hands-on learning opportunities, business schools can equip graduates with the specific skills and experiences that employers are seeking.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments