News

From Crisis to Change: Why Bad News Can Be Good News

October 18, 2022 1939

Can bad news about companies be good news for them? How should companies turn crisis management to change management?

(Photo: dreamtimes by license)

My recently published article, “Why bad news can be good news: The signaling feedback effect of negative media coverage of corporate irresponsibility,” published in Organization & Environment, explores these two questions using corporate social irresponsibility as the context. The study investigates how negative media coverage (signaling feedback) of corporate irresponsibility can elicit firms’ following positive corporate social responsibility (response signals).

Granted, no firms like bad media coverage. Bad news is absolutely bad news—think about angry customers, decreased sales, disinvestment, etc. However, what many firms tend to overlook is how bad media coverage also confers positive opportunities: it is a warning sign for the firm to initiate positive changes for its long-term success. Media coverage usually provides information that the focal firms did not normally have access to. For example, the media’s independent (free) research provides collected information from multiple stakeholders. These stakeholders even offer suggestions (again, free!). This is especially useful when it is about corporate social (ir)responsibility, which requires substantial stakeholder knowledge. Although not completely costless, all this information is invaluable feedback for the focal firms to understand what has gone wrong and where to move forward. Naturally, embedded in such media coverage crisis are great learning opportunities for firms’ long-term success.

Of course, not all firms can seize such learning opportunities, even if they know how invaluable these opportunities are. Firms need to know how to crack the code of the feedback. For example, what are the key needs behind all the reported stakeholder dissatisfaction? What is the relationship between different stakeholder demands? If a firm is a high-learning firm actively searching for new knowledge, typically in the form of research and development (R&D), it is in a better position to understand and exploit signaling feedback. This firm may be more capable of learning new information, inferring connections of seemingly unrelated information, and integrating new information into their existing knowledge. A case in point is my former company (Country Garden, a Fortune 500 property management company), which, in response to its workplace accident scandal, leveraged its R&D and developed robots to do dangerous activities.

Interestingly, my study also finds that for firms that do not have a strong learning capacity, negative media coverage can incentivize firms to learn in the form of R&D.  Some industry characteristics are also in play: firms that are already in R&D-intensive industries tend to increase their R&D more, considering the lower marginal costs. 

All the positive changes elicited by negative media coverage, be they small or large, suggest that firms can turn crisis management into change management, converting bad news to good news.

This study itself is a testimonial of learning from feedback. The editor and reviewers provided extremely insightful feedback, which gave me an incredible collaborative and learning experience. I certainly hope business and society can also engage in such collaborative learning to create a virtue cycle of business-society relationship.

Dr. Limin Fu is an assistant professor at the Monash Business School, Monash University. Her research investigates paradoxes in corporate social responsibility (CSR/ESG) and her research interests include strategic management, international business, and innovation.

View all posts by Limin Fu

Related Articles

Canada’s Storytellers Challenge Seeks Compelling Narratives About Student Research
Communication
November 21, 2024

Canada’s Storytellers Challenge Seeks Compelling Narratives About Student Research

Read Now
Deciphering the Mystery of the Working-Class Voter: A View From Britain
Insights
November 14, 2024

Deciphering the Mystery of the Working-Class Voter: A View From Britain

Read Now
How Managers Can Enhance Trust
Business and Management INK
November 11, 2024

How Managers Can Enhance Trust

Read Now
Doing the Math on Equal Pay
Insights
November 8, 2024

Doing the Math on Equal Pay

Read Now
Julia Ebner on Violent Extremism

Julia Ebner on Violent Extremism

As an investigative journalist, Julia Ebner had the freedom to do something she freely admits that as an academic (the hat she […]

Read Now
Ninth Edition of ‘The Evidence’: Tackling the Gender Pay Gap 

Ninth Edition of ‘The Evidence’: Tackling the Gender Pay Gap 

This month’s installment of The Evidence kicks off Gloria Media’s annual equal pay campaign. Starting from November 8, the average French woman […]

Read Now
The Conversation Podcast Series Examines Class in British Politics

The Conversation Podcast Series Examines Class in British Politics

Even in the 21st century, social class is a part of being British. We talk of living in a post-class era but, […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments