International Debate

Can a single case be used to test theory?

May 3, 2011 1086

This post is by Richard Nielsen on the Social Science Statistics Blog, hosted by the Institute for Quantitative Science at Harvard University.

Every so often, I try to take some time to read something that I should have read ages ago. Tonight’s gem was the 2010 draft of “The Industrial Organization of Rebellion: The Logic of Forced Labor and Child Soldiering” by Bernd Beber and Chris Blattman (link). The paper gets a lot of traction out of a formal model and then matches these predictions up to reality using some unique and hard-earned data.

An off-hand comment in the paper caught my attention: Beber and Blattman’s assertion that “a single case helps to refine our theory and validate some basic assumptions, but cannot test it” (p 19). Ordinarily I’d say “sure”, except that they are referring to their own nuanced analysis of a large number of child soldiers painstakingly tracked down in Uganda. Moreover, they actually have a credible identification strategy — abduction into the Lord’s Resistance Army was essentially random after conditioning on age and location. I was pretty convinced by the analysis; more so than by the regressions on the novel but dubious rebel dataset they introduce at the end of the paper. Maybe the Uganda child-soldier analysis wasn’t a “test” but it sure moved my posterior beliefs about their hypotheses…

Read the full blog-post here.

Related Articles

Deciphering the Mystery of the Working-Class Voter: A View From Britain
Insights
November 14, 2024

Deciphering the Mystery of the Working-Class Voter: A View From Britain

Read Now
Julia Ebner on Violent Extremism
Insights
November 4, 2024

Julia Ebner on Violent Extremism

Read Now
Emerson College Pollsters Explain How Pollsters Do What They Do
International Debate
October 23, 2024

Emerson College Pollsters Explain How Pollsters Do What They Do

Read Now
All Change! 2024 – A Year of Elections: Campaign for Social Science Annual Sage Lecture
Event
October 10, 2024

All Change! 2024 – A Year of Elections: Campaign for Social Science Annual Sage Lecture

Read Now
Exploring the ‘Publish or Perish’ Mentality and its Impact on Research Paper Retractions

Exploring the ‘Publish or Perish’ Mentality and its Impact on Research Paper Retractions

When scientists make important discoveries, both big and small, they typically publish their findings in scientific journals for others to read. This […]

Read Now
‘Settler Colonialism’ and the Promised Land

‘Settler Colonialism’ and the Promised Land

The term ‘settler colonialism’ was coined by an Australian historian in the 1960s to describe the occupation of a territory with a […]

Read Now
Webinar: Banned Books Week 2024

Webinar: Banned Books Week 2024

As book bans and academic censorship escalate across the United States, this free hour-long webinar gathers experts to discuss the impact these […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments